Healthy Eating Is A Disorder?

I saw this headline in Yahoo! News:

New Eating Disorders: Are They For Real?

Naturally, I was curious, so I clicked through. (If you’d like to read the whole article, click on the headline).

The two disorders?

  • adult picky eaters: adults who limit themselves to an extremely narrow range of foods
  • orthorexia: an obsession with healthy eating

I have to admit, my blood started to simmer when I read the second one. Just because eating unhealthily is the norm doesn’t make eating well on a consistent basis a disorder! But I continued reading.

The example case for orthorexia was a woman who eats only broccoli and cauliflower.

Obsession with healthful?

That is definitely disordered eating, and it’s not an obsession with being healthful. While both are great sources of many vitamins and minerals, they’re not sufficient to live on.

However, under the “What do they eat?” heading was the following:

Those affected may start by eliminating processed foods, anything with artificial colorings or flavorings as well as foods that have come into contact with pesticides. Beyond that, orthorexics may also shun caffeine, alcohol, sugar, salt, wheat and dairy foods. Some limit themselves to raw foods.

So anyone who considers themselves “raw” is disordered?  Eliminating processed foods and pesticides is disordered?

But wait!  The next section, “What are the risks?” makes me want to bang my head against a wall:

Social Isolation: Going to extremes in an effort to eat only healthy foods can also be socially isolating and can undermine personal relationships.

(The “also” was in there because social isolation was a risk factor for picky eating as well.)

Being highly restricted would definitely limit eating out with friends. That said, if the only activity you share with others is eating, there are other factors at work. Of course food is part of just about everything social that we do, but I can pretty easily go to a ball game, a concert, a movie, a dance, etc. without eating anything and without it being conspicuous. I can attend a potluck and bring a dish I can eat (which is what I do as a vegetarian anyway).

From what I understand, the raw community is pretty tight, so if you wanted to eat raw and live in an urban area, you are likely to find other like-minded people.

There are also quite a few other reasons that come to mind that would limit people’s ability to socialize with food. The first that pop into my head are food allergies/sensitivities.

So what do you think? Am I overreacting or is this a little bit crazy?

About these ads

2 responses to this post.

  1. I don’t think you are overreacting. It’s funny how people make up diagnoses for everything under the sun. Pregnancy is a diagnosis. I’m sorry… the last time I checked pregnancy isn’t a disease! It is a normal bodily process.

    Our society has become so normalized to UNhealthy food, that should be the disorder. Where is THAT in the page?

    malphagia (mal, meaning bad, wrongful) (phagia – to eat or ingest)- People who eat crappy foods that are no good for them, such as but not limited to: artificial flavors and colors, pesitcides, other harmful chemicals that are carginogenic, meats and dairy pumped full of hormones and antibiotics rather than clean facilities and regular sized, healthy animals, caffeine in excess, and a severe lack of raw fruits and vegetables.

    Other side effects: they feel too crappy to do anything else BUT eat, and have lost the ability to socialize any other way than eating at all you can eats, fast food restaurants, and other functions where food is key. These people may also think that because something is “common” it is considered “normal” and ok to continue.

    • I would love to see “eats only processed foods” as a disorder … but I don’t think it’s going to happen…

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 394 other followers

%d bloggers like this: